In proof of the previous statement that the treatment throughout
"Bridge Engineering" is based on the conception of economics, there is
offered the following extract from a review of that work written by Albert
Reichmann, Mem. Am. Soc. C.E., and published in the October, 1916,
issue of the Journal of the Western Society of Engineers.
"In a larger sense, this work is a treatise on the subject of 'Economics
of Bridge Engineering.' This train of thought can be traced throughout
the entire work, all subjects being treated fully and in a broad way, and
with the idea of value constantly brought out."
There is a salient feature of the present book to which attention should
be called, and that is the scarcity of treatment of economic problems by
pure mathematics, nearly all the formulae given being semi-rational, semi-empirical. The reason for this is that the conditions affecting most of the
economic questions in bridge designing are far too complicated to lend
themselves to solution by mathematical manipulations. This fact has not
always been recognized by engineering writers; for, during the last three or
four decades, numerous attempts have been made to settle important economic bridge-problems mathematically, with the result that the conclusions
thus drawn have proved to be erroneous and generally totally useless.
It is prognosticated that, in the future, there will be no such fundamental
changes in methods of bridge design and construction as to render really
incorrect the numerous economic conclusions reached herein; because
bridge building has now become fairly well systematized. About the only
important change in sight is the adoption of high-alloy steel for long-span
superstructures; and the effects of this have been duly anticipated. The
reasons for this belief are that the investigations upon which the book is
based were in general predicated upon fundamental engineering principles
that do not vary; and that the effects of possible changes in unit prices of
materials in place and in other general conditions affecting design have been
indicated. While it is true that an abnormal variation of a temporary
nature in the unit price of some important material of bridge construction,
some peculiar feature of structure-location affecting erection, or possibly
some other cause, may change somewhat the findings stated herein, it must
be remembered that, as pointed out in several places, up to a certain limit a
considerable divergence from the exact economic condition will usually
cause no serious augmentation of total cost. This is the saving clause
which renders the author's economic conclusions sufficiently dependable
for the future as well as for the present.
The story of the writing of this treatise is as follows:
In the summer of 1916, when "Bridge Engineering" was issued, the
author recognized that there was one very important bridge subject that
he had not completely covered, viz., economics; and he thereupon listed
ten major economic problems at that time unsolved, and came to the determination that they should no longer be left in that condition, if he could
prevent it. After repeatedly failing to interest any other investigator in
|