For many years the author's practice has been to stress the concrete in
compression only six hundred (600) pounds per square inch; but lately
the Joint Committee of the Technical Societies has reported in favor of
adopting six hundred and fifty (650) pounds. When a good aggregate is
procurable, the author has no objection to this increase of eight per cent;
but otherwise he prefers to adhere to his old custom, especially as by so
doing he adds only two per cent to the cost of the concrete in those cases
where the section can be reduced by using the higher intensity. Very
often, though, no such reduction is practicable, and the saving on the
entire job reduces to only one per cent.
The actual reduction in the amount of concrete in a beam due to this
difference of intensity of working stress is about six per cent, but this is
partially offset by an increase in the amount of steel required. The combination of the intensities of 600 for concrete and 16,000 for steel requires
a percentage of 0.68 for reinforcing steel, while with 650 and 16,000 that
figure is increased to 0.77. Moreover, construction work is simplified by
using more concrete and less steel, also better concrete is secured; hence
the author does not think that there is much real advantage in adopting
the higher intensity. The general complaint from contractors on his work
has been "too much steel"; and adopting the higher intensity for concrete
would make matters worse. Moreover, the use of heavier concrete sections
tends to keep down the shear intensity, which is always desirable.
Frequently there is a choice between a heavy concrete section with no
shear reinforcement, and a lighter section with such reinforcement. In
superstructure it is generally preferable to adopt the latter and in substructure the former.
Pavings
The subject of the economics of pavings is treated fully in Chapter XXI.
The economy lies in the cost of the pavement itself, excepting that brick
is heavier than the other paving materials; and, consequently, it adds to
the cost of a concrete structure, the amount being from two to three per
cent.
It is poor economy to neglect the expansion joints in block pavements;
because expansion is sometimes quite destructive, not only causing waves
in the pavement but sometimes actually pushing off the curbs.
Handrails
Handrails for reinforced-concrete bridges should always be made of concrete, in order to harmonize with the rest of the structure. A steel
railing on a concrete bridge is ruinous to the general appearance, and,
therefore, should not be tolerated. The first costs of the two types of
railing are about alike; but the concrete one, being heavier, requires more
|