In making the Detroit-Windsor Bridge study, a practical proof was
given of the usefulness of the paper. No copy of "Bridge Engineering"
was available for making an estimate of the cost of the suspension bridge
and its approaches, but a copy of the paper was at hand; and, as a rough
estimate was required immediately, the following procedure was adopted,
it being recognized at the outset that all the assumptions made therein
were upon the side of safety, and that, consequently, the resulting figures
of cost would be somewhat too great:
Referring to Fig. 13j, the curve for costs of suspension bridges was
extended on an enlarged cross-section sheet to a span of 1,700 feet, at
which length the spans on Fig. 13c begin. The cost thus found was mul-
tiplied by the ratio of the total combined clear widths of roadway and sidewalks for the two structures considered, and the product was multiplied
by the average of the ratios of the unit costs of all substructure and
superstructure materials in place for present conditions and the conditions assumed in the paper. Then, referring to Fig. 13c, it was noted
that the cost of a 2,500 foot-span suspension-bridge and its approaches
is almost exactly double that for a similar 1,700-foot span with its
approaches; hence the cost just found was doubled, and to the result
were added the cost of the entire flooring from entrance to exit of structure,
an allowance for the greater length of the approaches involved, and the
approximate cost of either elevators or an escalator and a stairway at the
Detroit approach.
Later, a more exact estimate of cost was made from the various data in
"Bridge Engineering," the result being some 5 per cent less than that of
the first approximation: This more-exact estimate was computed in a
single working day. Without the aid of the book mentioned, it would
probably have required as many weeks of figuring as it actually took hours
thereof, in order to obtain results of equal accuracy.
In the Appendix to the original paper there are given five pages of
estimates of cost, covering fourteen structures out of the twenty-five that
were computed. It has not been deemed worth while to reproduce them
in this treatise; for probably they would not be of much interest to any
reader. If, though, anyone desires to see them, he can do so by consulting
the Transactions of the Western Society of Engineers.
|